Fact check: Comparison of COVID-19 case data based on state politics is wrong

Fact check: Comparison of COVID-19 case data based on state politics is wrong

The claim: COVID-19 is worse in Democratic states because of government action

Americans' coronavirus pandemic experience is increasingly different, as states and cities ease social distancing orders and debate next steps for containing the virus.

Some people have pointed to differences in the reported number of cases by state as a sign of partisan incompetence.

A graphic on Facebook displays the population of two sets of states alongside the number of confirmed coronavirus cases and deaths in each grouping. The statistics in the graphic are said to come from April 20. The photo has been shared several hundred times on Facebook across multiple accounts, and has also appeared on Twitter.

Another similar image on Instagram has the same states and claims to provide coronavirus data for April 26.

The statistics in the graphics are inaccurate. While government action has been significant in determining the spread of COVID-19, underlying regional factors are more likely the cause of diverging case numbers between states.

Fact check:What's true and what's false about coronavirus?

COVID-19 statistics by state

The graphics specify 20 states, separating them by perceived partisan lean. It lists New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, California, Michigan, Illinois, Louisiana, Connecticut and Maryland as states run or controlled by Democrats. And it lists Texas, Florida, Ohio, Arizona, Tennessee, Indiana, Missouri, South Carolina, Alabama and Oklahoma as being run or controlled by Republicans.

One group of states, which are mostly governed by Democrats (Maryland has a Republican governor), is said to have a population of 104.8 million people. According to Census Bureau estimates, the 10 states had a combined population of over 124 million in 2019.

The second group of states, which are governed by Republicans, is said to have a population of 103.1 million in the graphic. This number is in line with Census Bureau estimates for 2019.

According to data collected from state public health departments by USA TODAY, the combined number of cases in those states governed by Democrats was 534,570 on April 20. That is about 40,000 fewer cases than reported in the graphic. The actual death toll was also lower by 4,998, at 29,628.

More:Trump accuses Democratic governors of keeping lockdowns because of 'politics' as he visits Michigan

The Republican-governed states conversely reported higher numbers of cases and deaths than the graphic claims. According to data from April 20, 101,664 cases were reported in the second grouping of states compared to — 97,150 in the image — with 3,827 deaths, which is 1,201 higher than in the image.

The number of infections and deaths rose in both groups of states over time. By April 26, when new graphics made similar claims about the states, coronavirus cases in the "Democrat-run" grouping had reached 687,654, with 38,477 deaths. The graphic states there were 44,924 deaths at that time.

"Republican-run" states also had a jump in the collective number of cases, reaching 125,520 confirmed coronavirus infections by April 26 and 4,566 deaths. The graphic puts the number of deaths at 4,610.

The number of cases has grown across the United States in the interceding month, though many officials have cited slower infection rates as a reason to begin easing social distancing measures.

A USA TODAY investigation also found that many states are likely significantly under-reporting the number of COVID-19 cases. A lack of accurate and widespread testing has made it difficult to detect and track the virus across the country.

An analysis by 24/7 Wall St. found that many of the states with the highest daily infection rates are in the Northeast and mid-Atlantic regions, states which are mostly governed by Democrats. That said, infectious disease experts have attributed this to correlation, not causation.

More:Coronavirus spread: In which states is COVID-19 growing fastest?

Demographics, geography and COVID-19

Public health experts have gained greater clarity into how COVID-19 is most likely to spread. There is consensus, for instance, that people are more likely to contract COVID-19 from contact with an infected person by breathing and coughing or even just talking, especially indoors.

Dr. Joseph Eisenberg, a professor of epidemiology at the University of Michigan, cites a region’s density and connectivity to other locales as important factors in its likely transmission rate. In other words, major international travel hubs with high density are the areas most vulnerable to an outbreak.

“New York City has exceptionally high density,” Eisenberg noted, which likely explains part of its severe outbreak. Other factors, like the underlying behavior and health conditions in a population, are also important in determining the spread of a virus.

In a country as large and varied as the United States, regional differences in case numbers are to be expected, according to Eric Toner, an infectious disease expert at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

“As the virus spreads from place to place over time some places will be seeing rising numbers while others are seeing falling numbers or may not have even been affected yet,” Toner told USA TODAY. “Local differences such as population density, demographic factors and local industries will also greatly affect the number of cases.”

Our ruling: False

We rate this claim FALSE because it is not supported by our research. The statistics in the circulating graphic are inaccurate. Regional differences in case numbers and deaths from COVID-19 are primarily explained by underlying factors, including density and the demographics of those infected.

Our fact-check sources:

Census Bureau, State population estimates for 2019USA TODAY, Coronavirus cases are likely artificially low in some states thanks to flawed testing27/4 Wall St., Coronavirus spread: In which states is COVID-19 growing fastest?USA TODAY, Simply talking in confined spaces may be enough to spread the coronavirus, researchers say

Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.

Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.

Source: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/06/05/fact-check-comparison-covid-19-data-state-politics-false/5252816002/

News Related


Trump’s ‘mission accomplished’ moment is premature and deadly. We have not defeated COVID.

Desperate for crowds and adoration, Trump has put his most fervent supporters at risk of getting a deadly disease. Future historians will be astonished. Read more »

NFLPA president JC Tretter says NFL is putting season, players at risk with its coronavirus approach

NFL Players Association president JC Tretter said Tuesday the NFL is putting the 2020 season at risk with its coronavirus approach, calling on the league to better “prioritize player safety.” “Like many other... Read more »

Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro says he tested positive for the coronavirus

RIO DE JANEIRO (AP) — Brazil’s President Jair Bolsonaro says he has tested positive for COVID-19 after months of downplaying the virus’ severity. Bolsonaro confirmed the test results while wearing a mask and... Read more »

Venice Film Festival forges ahead amid COVID-19 pandemic with reduced lineup

The show will go on for the Venice Film Festival in September, but with a few modifications due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Organizers said Tuesday that they are pushing forward with plans for... Read more »

Amtrak offers buy-one, get-one promotion on its sleeper trains amid COVID-19 — with a catch

Amtrak wants you to have sweet dreams the next time you travel — so much so that it’s sweetening the deal on its sleeper “roomettes.” The rail service is offering a buy-one-get-one-free discount... Read more »

Florida teen treated with hydroxychloroquine at home before dying of COVID-19, report says

FORT MEYERS, Fla. – The family of a 17-year-old Florida girl who died last month from COVID-19 treated her symptoms at home for nearly a week before taking her to a hospital, a... Read more »

Mookie Betts worried MLB coronavirus testing woes could prevent him from ever playing for Dodgers

During nearly four months away from the game, Mookie Betts said he “stayed away from baseball to keep myself sane.” It’s not hard to understand why. The 2018 American League Most Valuable Player... Read more »

Tom Hanks doesn’t get ‘how common sense has somehow been put into question’ with coronavirus

Read more »

Can Gov. DeSantis force Florida schools to reopen amid the coronavirus pandemic? Some school leaders seem doubtful.

PALM BEACH, Fla. — As concern about the state order spread online, some school leaders said: Not so fast. As Florida educators puzzle over how to start the new academic year, Gov. Ron... Read more »

Texas surpasses 200,000 coronavirus cases after 4th of July holiday weekend

AUSTIN, Texas – Texas reached 200,000 total COVID-19 cases Monday, just 17 days after crossing the 100,000 threshold, a figure that took the state nearly four months to hit. The grim milestone came... Read more »